Most doctors encourage women to have regular mammograms
Routine breast cancer screening may have little effect on reducing deaths from the disease and the value of national programs should be questioned, according to a new report.
A study by the Nordic Cochrane Centre in Copenhagen, published today in the British Medical Journal, concludes that national screening programs bring no benefit in terms of lives saved. The study, based on the Danish program, is the latest work to raise questions about the efficacy of population-wide mammographies. It comes as the world’s leading disease experts gather at the European Breast Cancer Conference in Barcelona.
All women aged between 50 and 70 are offered breast cancer screening in Britain, with more than 1.7 million taking up the invitation every year.
The latest findings, based on analysis of data over a 20-year period covering the introduction of regional screening in Denmark, found that breast cancer mortality fell by 1 per cent per year in the screened areas and by 2 per cent per year in non-screened areas.
The research authors, from the University of Copenhagen and the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, conclude that they could find no effect of the Danish program on death rates.
They write: “Our results are similar to what has been observed in other countries with nationally organized programs. We believe it is time to question whether screening has delivered the promised effect on breast cancer mortality.”
The Government, health charities and most doctors encourage women to have regular mammograms in this country on the basis of estimates that the checks save 1,400 lives each year.
However, last year a group of leading health professionals told The Times that women undergoing routine breast cancer screening were not being warned of the risks, with many tests ending in needless treatment. They criticized the Government’s “unethical” failure to provide women with the full facts in the NHS program of checks, prompting the Department of Health to review its information leaflets.
Of the 2.2 million women invited for checks by the NHS breast screening program in 2007-08, 1.7 million were screened — up half a million on a decade ago. The number of cancer cases detected by screening has more than doubled over the same period to 14,100 in 2007-08.
However, a spokesman for the NHS Screening Programmes said that leading epidemiologists had raised queries about the methodology and comparisons made in the latest Cochrane study. He said that the conclusions published in the BMJ added little to the continuing analysis of breast screening.
Professor Julietta Patnick, the director of the NHS Cancer Screening Programmes, said: “Rigorous independent research has shown that the NHS screening program saves lives. This is a report relating to the Danish screening program, which is significantly different from the English system.”
A report from the World Health Organisation’s International Agency for Research on Cancer suggested a 35 per cent reduction in mortality from breast cancer among regularly screened women between 50 and 69 years old.
Via Times Online